Wednesday, October 26, 2016
Austerity in Greece a Remedy not a Penalty for Self-made Ills
By Con George-Kotzabasis --September 23, 2016
My short reply to a political theorist of the Jurgen Habermas School of Critical Theory
It is rather surprising to see a votary of Jurgen Habermas in using an analytic blunted tool that leads to the false inference that malevolent Europeans wilfully imposed upon Greece austerity measures to punish it. The truth is, that these measures were saddled upon Greece as a result of a consumer’s binge and an exuberance of public spending, fuelled, by a profusion of borrowed funds which inevitably pushed Greece into the quagmire of bankruptcy. Austerity therefore and the economic structural changes imposed on the country were a remedy, not a penalty, for the self-inflicted ills that past government policies, mainly of Pasok, engendered.
My question is, why you have not mentioned anything of the pledges, that Kyriakos Mitsotakis had made in his speech at the Exhibition of Thessalonica last Saturday, with their great potential to pull Greece out of its long economic crisis. In my opinion, a government, under the strong and astute leadership of Mitsotakis, will pull Greece out of its immiseration—as the Samaras government was close in achieving. An immiseration that the totally inept Tsipras government is exacerbating, with its historically obsolete neo-Marxist fixations and panaceas.
Labels:
europeans,
greece,
malevolent,
mitsotakis,
panacea,
penalty,
remedy,
samaras government
Monday, September 19, 2016
Democracy Being a Free Good Endangers its Existence
By Con George-Kotzabasis
Breathing democratic
freedom is neither easy nor free; it entails both rights and obligations and
most importantly knowledge of current fundamental issues. But in most
democracies their constituents tend to uphold and demand more their rights than
their obligations, and more deplorably, a sizable number of them exercise their
rights in a state of ignorance. This imbalance, however, between rights and
obligations, as well as lack of knowledge of the real issues, puts in jeopardy
the functioning of a politically just and economically productive democracy, and
indeed endangers its existence as a form of government.
Moreover, it makes its
voters who are uninformed of the points at issue captive to populist slogans
and to that everlasting traducer of democracy, identified by Aristotle, demagogy,
that appeals to the hopes and fears of the electors and by
propagandistic lies and false promises opens the doors of power to demagogues.
This is exemplified by two recent political events in our times: Alexis Tsipras
and his party of Syriza winning the elections in Greece on a wave of populism
and unprecedented lies and false promises in the political history of the
country, and of the plebiscite of the UK, whose two leaders of Brexit, Boris
Johnson and Nigel Farage, with a farrago of lies and dire fictions were able to
hoodwink a major part of the populace to vote for the exit of Britain from the
European Union. On a smaller scale this also has happened in the Australian
elections, when the Labor Party by its scare campaign that the Liberal
Coalition would privatize Medicare, succeeded in convincing a large part of the
electorate of this fictitious threat with the result of Liberals losing so many
seats that brought the country on the edge of a hang parliament.
How can one remedy the
weaknesses of democracy and protect its constituents from becoming victims to
populism and to demagogy with catastrophic results to the well-being of society
and to its continued economic prosperity? Some people believe that the answer
lies in bringing cultural and ethical changes among the people that would make
them immune to this toxic virus of populist-demagogy; and thus leading gradually
to the cashiering and inexorable dismissal of all demagogic and populist
leaders from the domain of politics. The difficulty and danger of such a
solution however is that cultural change is a slow process and during its gestation
and vicissitudes in a long run may in the meantime unhinge democracy from its
door of freedom, by the actions of feckless, inept, and irresponsible
politicians, and incarcerate it within the dungeon of dictatorship. A safer and
faster solution would be to enact radical changes to the electoral voting
system by suspending in certain circumstances temporarily parts of the
electorate from voting.
On what principle could one
suggest such an unequal voting system that would discriminate so deliberately
between social groups in the ambience of democracy, and which group would be
the unequal part in the democratic process? The guiding principle of the first
part of the question must explicitly aim to the continued viability and
stability of a democratic system, in the context of which, the economic
well-being of society depends and guarantees the further expansion of wealth that
renders to the people a wide choice where to employ their talents and skills
that would push their living standard onto higher plateaus and make their lives
congenial to their desires. The second part, i.e., the social group that would
be unequally treated, would be identified as that part that depends
on welfare for its living and as a ‘debtor’ client of the government easily
succumbs to populist slogans and rabble rousing; also, due to its low educational
level and lack of interest in important matters, it deprives it from having
adequate knowledge of the issues involved and hence is completely unqualified
to make a sober judgment on these issues. It is mainly this social group that
brings to power demagogues and millenarian ideologues that imperil the
stability of the polity and its economic system. And, indeed, ironically pits
this same social group into absolute poverty, and in turn destabilizes
democracy itself, as it has happened with the political rise of Hugo Chavez and
Nicolas Maduro in Venezuela; where its people after a contrived false
prosperity are presently hunting dogs and cats to feed themselves. The same has
happened with the Marxist Alexis Tsipras in Greece, where the pauperization of
many of its ordinary people is exacerbated every day and has reached unprecedented
high levels under his totally inept, ideologically barren and irresponsible
government.
The enactment of this
radical legislation would specifically suspend from the right to vote any
person who had been on social welfare or unemployed for more than a year, and
only with his/her ceasing on being on welfare or unemployed his/her right to
vote would be restored. Such legislation would not only strengthen and secure
the viability of democracy and the prosperity of its economic system, but would
also deprive populist demagogues and political parties of a constituency upon
whose existence they depend. Moreover, it would substantially reduce the spending
of the welfare state and make it less precarious to the fiscal policy of the
state and hence to the well-being of the country. This radical enactment takes
a leaf from the cradle of democracy in classical Greece, Athenian democracy.
The latter disenfranchised and suspended from voting citizens who had failed to
pay a debt to the polis. Likewise, in a modern democracy people who were in
debt for their living to the government, that is on
welfare, would be suspended from casting a vote.
Needless to say, such a
radical proposal, to occur in the ambit of the 'spoils' of the welfare state
that has spoiled at least two generations of people by our carefree and stand
at ease democracy, will not be easy to implement as it will rouse all the wrath
and opposition of the ‘progressive’ bien
pensants and the ‘good fellows’ of the dole. It will require
extraordinarily strong and sagacious political leadership that will unite parliamentary
opposition parties into a gigantic wave that relentlessly will sweep away this ‘progressivist’
praetorian guard of the human rights, without responsibilities, of the dole
takers, and throw this defiance of the sanctimonious goody-goodies into the
dust bin of history.
I rest on my oars: Your turn now
Thursday, August 4, 2016
How the Good Intentions of a Left-wing Economist Lead to Bad Results
By Con George-Kotzabasis May 19, 2016
The following is an unconsummated reply to professor Andrew Leigh’s lecture with the title, “Markets Monopolies and Moguls…” held at Melbourne University, on May 19, 2016. This was due to the chairman’s instruction that only a sprinkle of questions would follow the end of the presentation and there would be no debate
I’m overly distrustful of people who use scarecrows, in this case the “mogul” Richard Pratt, to make their argument. Moreover, it is a term associated with sinister practices and easily tantalizes and incites the feelings of the crowd to purge the evildoers. But more dismally it is wrong in your case, as it is an exercise in a fallacy of composition: Just because there are few rotten apples in the cart it does not mean that all apples are rotten. The unprecedented prosperity of capitalism was not engendered by rottenness but by the creative, innovative, and dynamic spirit of entrepreneurship.
The great economic historian, Fernand Braudel, depicts the shifts of capitalist centres and their entrepreneurial moguls, from Venice, Genoa, Antwerp, Amsterdam, London, to New York, spreading boundless prosperity to these metropolises and their environs by means of the ceaseless division of labour, international trade and the capitalist dynamic ethos of entrepreneurial creation. It was the sun-king of entrepreneurial capitalism that had pulled millions of people out of the sunless caves of poverty into the sunlit vistas of capitalist plenitude, heightening their standard of living, for the first time in history, on ever-higher plateaus.
(The scientific writer, Arthur Koestler, contends that the great discoveries of science were motivated by ambition, competition, and vanity, which happen also to be the inherent characteristics of capitalist moguls.)
You have mentioned a lot of negatives about “bigness” and market concentration but not the fact that they rather have a short life since there is no blockage of entry in a competitive economy to other entrepreneurs into these concentrated areas. One example, the entry of the innovative entrepreneur ALDI into the food-chain services and its reduction of the prices of its products in comparison to other chains, not only attracted many consumers to its stores but also forced the other two major super markets of COLES and WOOLWORTHS to reduce their prices at the feel of the competitive pinch of the newcomer. Competition does not discriminate between big and small but it equally affects both.
But to deal with your argument that inequality should be a major consideration in competition policy, and regulating mergers and prices would be beneficial to the consumer. The competitive market in itself, without the need of regulation, spreads its cheaper products to an ever-greater number of consumers and therefore decreases inequality. The competition of Telstra and Optus is an example. The same applies to iPods. Ride a train, a bus, or a tram and you will see even the lower classes fully equipped with these cheaper gadgets of a competitive technology and once again the line of inequality is lowered down for the less wealthy consumer.
It is not the business of government to regulate mergers and pricing. This is the bailiwick of entrepreneurs who decide if such a merger will be profitable, whether it will be able to compete with an already established corporation producing the same product, and setting its price on such a level that it will attract consumers to buy its product en masse.
Furthermore, as far as the regulation is close to the estimates and interests of the entrepreneurs it is superfluous; and as far as it is distanced from these estimates and interests, it is destructive. No businessman will invest his money in a venture where profit is unattainable. Hence, your regulation, that aborts the setting-up of a merger that would produce cheaper products for the consumer, by depriving the latter from having these goods, increases the inequality of the mass consumer. Not surprisingly, as often happens, good intentions lead to bad results.
Therefore, your proposal of government dirigisme as a panacea in regards to competition and regulation is inutile, fanciful, and fallacious, and more perniciously may turn out to be a destructive force.
I rest on my oars: Your turn now
Labels:
andrew leigh,
destructive force,
incites,
kotzabasis,
mogul,
purge,
sinister practices,
tantalizes
Sunday, July 17, 2016
Smart Politicians Stand Naked Before Labor's Master: Ideological Stupidity
By Con George-Kotzabasis June 28, 2016
Since the economically profligate Whitlam era,
the only Labor government that was bracketed off from Labor’s inveterate stupidity
was the Hawke-Keating government. The present leadership of Shorten-Bowen
taking a leftist turn in its politics, like the Rudd-Gillard administrations
had done, as adumbrated in its pre-electoral commitments of “big-government,”
is repudiating the prudent policies of Hawke-Keating and wilfully adopting,
retrogressively, the stupid and disastrous paradigm of European socialism that
had sunk Spain, Portugal, Ireland, Greece and Cyprus into the abyss of
bankruptcy, economic crisis, and political instability. Moreover, it is doing
so in the face when even the Scandinavian haven of the social democratic
Welfare state is severely clipped of its largesse, as at last has been realised
to be no longer economically viable. Anders Borg, the wunderkind as finance minister of Sweden, initiated the incremental
dismantling of the Welfare state, lowered taxes in the private sector, which has
galvanized the creation of new jobs.
Returning back home. The leftist political
editor of The Sydney Morning Herald, Mark
Kenny, is forecasting “dire trouble” for Labor on the debt and deficit front.
Terry McCrann, of The Daily Telegraph, ominously
declares “Shorten would plunge the country into greater debt”. And Henry Ergas,
of The Australian, claims that even
the latest backflips of Labor will not be sufficient to close the deficit gap
and its “mythmakers” will be tempted “to conjure revenue increases out of thin
air, just as the Rudd-Gillard governments did pointing to a golden future time
when receipts would soar.”
But to believe in myths and tales of future
increases in revenue, when The World Bank
and the International Monetary Fund slash
hopes of economic growth in the near future, is highly precarious, as it would
lead the country into complacency and prevent it from taking the necessary
measures to countervail a looming long recession. Furthermore, such a possibility
is strengthened with the present event of Brexit, which could ominously beget
both the dismemberment and the disintegration of the UK and the European Union,
whose widespread ramifications upon the geopolitical and economic spheres of
the world would devastate any prospects of economic growth for many years. And
it is most unlikely that there will be, like in 2008, another China to save
Australia from woeful economic distress.
Further, Labor with egregious lack of
imagination and foresight is not factoring-in such imponderables as a
precipitous fall in world prices of minerals in a context of world recession and
the calamitous consequences that would follow, hitting public finances to
smithereens and engendering a seriality of deficits with no hope of being
reduced, with the outcome of plunging the country into the abyss of bottomless
debt and insolvency. Is Bill Shorten going to be the “Maduro” of Australia,
who, as the world price of oil dropped to lower depths, as a socialist president
of Venezuela, continued the dissolute economic policies of his predecessor,
Chavez, that turned the country from contrived prosperity to real poverty, once
the government coffers were emptied, and indeed, into a hunting ground for dogs
and cats to feed his people?
It goes without saying, of course, that this is
an exaggeration and one could hardly imagine Australians shooting dogs and cats
to feed themselves. It is merely used as an example to emphasize the dangers
overshadowing an economy, when its Stewarts, the government, insouciantly do
not take in consideration future possible events that could dramatically affect
the economic course of a country and do not take prospective measures that
would shield the country from such catastrophic effects.
One asks the question why the smart as they
come politicians of Labor, such as Andrew Leigh, the assistant shadow treasurer
of Labor, let their guard down and are reluctant to prepare themselves for
these uncertainties of the future, believing that Australia somehow is
protected by divine mandate from the ills of world recession and that
Australia’s “economy is indestructible”, to quote Rex Connor, a minister in Whitlam’s
government?
For people who have studied the policies of Labor over a number of
years the answer is simple and obvious. All their major policies are motivated
by their passionate belief in the socialist utopia. And the implementation of
these policies requires, according to this ideological schema, big and
interventionist government and hence, high taxes; and the redistribution of
wealth and not its greater increase are their priority. Despite the glaring
evidence showing that augmenting the size of wealth is the only and sure way to
enhance the standard of living of the ordinary people. The latter proposition has
indisputable historical precedents, as it was the flourishing and ever
increasing wealth of capitalism, that for the first time in history, pulled millions
of people from the hovels of poverty onto peaks of prosperity. But Labor is
blind before this historical fact. Like a drug addict Labor is fixed to its socialist doctrine and
lives in a stupefied world of unreality and wishful thinking.
The matchsticks foundations of socialism are collapsing
all over the world, especially in Europe, yet Bill Shorten’s Labor continues adamantly
to believe that from this wreckage one could still build the just and equal
society as envisaged by Labor’s quixotic visionaries. It is under this standard
of socialist ideology that Shorten undermines and repudiates the prudent and
pragmatic policies of the Hawke-Keating government, whose “Accord” between
employers and workers engendered a congenial milieu for investments and the
creation of new jobs with the consequence of increasing the living standard of
Australians. Bill Shorten’s silence about these productive structural reforms
and fiscal frugality of the Hawke-Keating era that had put Australia on a track
of prosperity is a contemptuous affront to the two architects of these reforms.
It was therefore rather surprising and amusing to have seen the two conductors
of this inimitable political and economic performance sitting on the front-row
of Shorten’s Launch of the Labor campaign, clapping at a leader who had
mockingly renounced their wise policies. For Paul Keating, especially, standing
next to Bill Shorten who had adopted and announced policies that would lead to
a “Banana Republic,” it must have been an exceedingly painful occasion. Perhaps
as painful as replacing Placedo Domingo with rock-and-roll.
I
rest on my oars: You turn now
Labels:
anders borg,
bill shorten hawke,
deficit,
government,
greece,
Keating,
placedo domingo,
welfare
Tuesday, May 10, 2016
Marx and his Modern Reincarnation Continues to be Hotbed of Gross Errata
By Con George-Kotzabasis
The
following is a very brief reply to professor of economics Kostas Lapavitsas,
and former member of Parliament with the Party of Syriza, to his thesis, that Greece
can achieve its national sovereignty only by going back to its own currency,
i.e., the drachma, delivered at the Ithacan House, Melbourne, on April 15,
2016. The three first paragraphs were omitted from my response as I assumed regrettably
wrongly, that the time allotted to the questioners at the meeting would be too
short and hence I did not include them.
Professor Lapavitsas, allow me to make a short comment
before I come to my question, as at the start I want to point out what I believe
to be the roots of your erroneous proposition.
Dialectical materialism even in its modern
reincarnation of neo-Marxism, which you espouse, is a hotbed of gross errata, not to say terata (monsters), and hence
a fallacious doctrine.
Yet the ghost in the machine of Marxism,
despite its irreparable breakdown, continues to churn-out apparitional panaceas for
the ills of global capitalism. One such quack panacea is your own proposition.
My question is: Show us one country in the world hit
by absolute poverty, which, your implied return to the drachma entails, that by
adopting your proposal has achieved national sovereignty and kept it; If you
cannot show us such a country, then your proposal is a mirage, a
will-o’-the-wisp, an occult fancy.
But what is more worrisome is that you are asking the
Greek people, after the botched Tsipras-Varoufakis experiment, to be also the guineapigs to your own theoretical experiment which has hardly better odds of success
than the Varoufakian one.
National sovereignty is the result of prosperity
not of poverty.
.
Labels:
greece,
kotzabasis,
marx,
poverty,
professor lapavitsas,
proposition,
tsipras,
varoufakis
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
